Back to On the Head of a Pin THEN: Castiel came back to capture Alastair, the evil demon who tortured Dean in Hell. Sam continued to flex his incredibly powerful evil demon-crushing power. NOW: Castiel finds a dead angel with her chest ripped apart. He and Uriel seek out Sam and Dean, who are a…
Back to Death Takes a Holiday Greybull, Wyoming Two guys emerge from a goal and discuss their fantasy football game. A mugger approaches them in the alleyway and ends up shooting one of them, Jim Jenkins. The mugger runs off and Jim’s friend tries to revive him. Jim gets up and reveals that the…
Back to Sex and Violence Bedford, Iowa Vicki Benson is tenderizing meat for supper when her husband Adam comes home late from work. When she talks about his boss keeping him late, he snaps at her and then apologizes. As she explains that she accepted a party invitation for a friend, he loses his temper…
Back to After-School Special Fairfax, Indiana At Truman High School, the cheerleaders and jocks are gossiping about Taylor, and when she arrives tell her she can’t sit with them. They accuse her of being a slut and she sits next to another girl, April. April tells Taylor to ignore them and she feels sorry, but…
Back to Criss Angel Is a Douche Bag It’s Magic Week in Sioux City, Iowa, and The Incredible Jay, an older magician. is fumbling through a magic trick at a bar. Another magician, Patrick Vance, drunkenly mocks him from down the bar. Jay wanders over and ruins the trick. Later on stage, Jay reviews a…
Back to Family Remains At a farmhouse, Bill Gibson is watching TV when the lights go out. He goes to the fuse box but discovers that the door wont’ open. A door opens behind him and a pale woman comes in. The man recognizes her but says it’s impossible for her to be there. He…
Back to Heaven and Hell Uriel tells the Winchesters to get out of the way so he can kill Anna. Castiel admits that they’re heartless, and says that Anna is worse than a demon. Uriel repeats his demand and when they refuse, the angel smashes Ruby into the wall. Dean tries to attack him but…
Back to I Know What You Did Last Summer At a hospital, a woman, Anna Milton, is staring off into space. The doctor asks if she knows where she is and if she remembers what she did. Anna says she was trying to warn everyone but realizes it was stupid. The doctor pursues the matter…
Back to Wishful Thinking A girl, Candace Armstrong, is taking a shower, unaware of a teenage boy appearing in the room behind her. As she turns, he disappears. As she dries her hair, his hand print appears on the steamed mirror. His footprints appear on the wet tiles as he approaches her. The girl thinks…
Back to It’s the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Two Days Before Halloween The town is preparing for Halloween and a mother returns home as her husband Luke Wallace feeds their baby child. The wife puts the candy away and takes the baby upstairs. Once she’s gone, her husband gets into the candy and has a…