Clap Your Hands If You Believe Cast

Ben Edlund

John Showalter

Robert Picardo Wayne Whittaker, Jr.
Linden Banks Mr. Brennan
Trish Allen Marion
Devon Weigel Sparrow Jennings
Rob Morton Sheriff
Stefan Arngrim Redcap
Joel Hayes Patrick Brennan
MacKenzie Porter Patrick's Girlfriend
Sienna Bohn Attractive Waitress
Joe Allard Elf
Stephen Watts Elf
Jameson Trensholm Elf
Rick McLean Elf
Alisha Newton Little Girl
Colin Naples District Attorney